Another article
against police socialism.
"Mises identified the inability to engage in economic calculation as the
key practical limitation of socialism that rendered it unworkable. This
incapacity to divert resources to their most urgent use is one of the
most conspicuous results of a socialist criminal justice system. Thus do
we see police expending hundreds of thousands of dollars arresting,
prosecuting, and punishing an individual for a victimless crime, when it
is hard to imagine a private institution finding such a witch hunt
economically viable."
No kidding.
"The state has every incentive to expand its activity into nearly any
area that the people will tolerate, regardless of whether such activity
makes economic or moral sense. Since it monopolizes conflict resolution —
and acting in this capacity is another opportunity to expand its size
and reach — the state actually has an interest in fomenting conflict,
thereby maximizing its role in society. The more crime and punishment,
no matter their effect on the innocent, and the more laws, no matter how
outrageous or contradictory, the more business for the state, which, in
a supreme conflict of interest, gets to determine what the laws are."
This is true for every service government provides. This is why government never cures diseases.
"In practice, law-enforcement socialism is even worse than socialism
in most other areas, since it involves a state monopoly on legal
violence, and thus is expected to act coercively. Whenever an innocent
person is brutalized — which will happen about as often as we could
expect any kind of mistake from government work — it is seen as a small
price to pay to protect the innocent.
As terrible as it is to allow central planners to decide how and
where to produce shoes, cars, or widgets and where to divert them, it is
a bigger problem when central planners are given free rein to decide
how force is to be used in all of society. Indeed, by capitulating to
its monopoly on violence, we accept its very power to monopolize and
socialize. Freedom is never secure so long as a ruling class of people
is permitted to monopolize the very means of monopolization, from which
further abuses of the market and liberty can only follow."
That's a real good point for people who advocate limited government.
"When a welfare state worker gets it wrong, it is a waste of resources
and can create waves of disastrous social repercussions. When a law
enforcer gets it wrong — or searches and seizes the innocent in pursuit
of the guilty — justice itself has been defiled and liberty attacked. "
Or somebody gets killed.
No comments:
Post a Comment